Page 1 of 4

What category is Moya's music?

PostPosted: Fri Sep 19, 2003 9:34 pm
by Daragh
I was just thinking about how Moya is always put in the New Age category for the Grammy awards so I would like to know what the fans think and maybe we can let the industry know our thoughts also.

Help me out here :?:

Daragh

PostPosted: Fri Sep 19, 2003 10:01 pm
by Jim
I would not classify her as "New Age". I associate that term more with synth-based instrumental music, which her music is most definitely not. I also associate that term with neo-pagan philosophy, to which she does not subscribe.

I think that term, in association with her music, comes from the music industry's tendency to pigeonhole everything into a category, and everything that can't be pigeonholed otherwise is put into the "New Age" category.

I would put her in the "Moyabrennan" category. She is one of a kind! :D

Not sure...

PostPosted: Fri Sep 19, 2003 10:01 pm
by gregoing
Hi, everyone. I voted "not sure" because some of her music could be classified as New Age, and some as Christian. I think her first two albums and her latest one could be classified as New Age, while "Perfect Time" and "Whisper to the Wild Water" Christian. I didn't vote "New Age" or "Christian" because I don't think you can really place all five of her albums into one category. Nor did I vote "other" because I don't really believe you could list her music into another category except Folk (yet when many people think of folk, they think of traditional, old-sounding music, which I don't see Moya's music as being) or Classical (again, I don't think classical would be appropriate for Moya's music, either)...

-Greg

PostPosted: Fri Sep 19, 2003 11:35 pm
by Ageless Messanger
Also voted for 'Not Sure' because I'm not really sure, either, as to what her music would be classified as.



A.M.

Other

PostPosted: Fri Sep 19, 2003 11:48 pm
by Richard Fethers
I voted Other as I think Moya's music is neither New Age or Christian. More Celtic because of the influence her "harp" playing has. Its definitely of a modern strand of Celtic in its instrumentation but in many instances based on folk law....and what a voice!
Cheers,
Richard

PostPosted: Sat Sep 20, 2003 12:50 am
by Endymion
For me is New Age/Celtic/Jazz or simply Moya.
Moya,Enya and Clannad are in the same category that I want to follow in music.

I'm not sure either!

PostPosted: Sat Sep 20, 2003 8:41 am
by cantilena91
For me, Moya's music is only wonderful to be listened to and very beautifully done, so I don't like categorising her music at all! There's no need for categorising, I think...

Suvi

PostPosted: Sat Sep 20, 2003 9:52 am
by Mike:-)
Well said, Suvi. For us, fans, there's no need for categorising Moya's music. But it's the thing to do for the music industry (they just have to be sure where to place the CD in the shops). As Moya's music is so complex, they've got a big problem :D

PostPosted: Sat Sep 20, 2003 10:23 am
by Phantas
I voted "Other" because I too believe Moya is a representative of "Celtic" music (instead of just FOLK).

I wouldn't put her music under Christian as, although many songs by her are aimed at God etc., I also believe many "pagans" (like me, considering I do not believe in God) like listening to her music, even though it has a Christian message.
To put her under New Age is going a bit too far, as I wouldn't be able to relax to any of her cd's, and because her music is very world-like. So categorize her under World Music, really, if you must.

to Vote not sure means, to me at least, that you don't have a clue what Moya's music sounds like, IMHO, to be honest. No offence :)

Love,
Phantas

"other"...

PostPosted: Sat Sep 20, 2003 4:35 pm
by gregoing
Phantas wrote:to Vote not sure means, to me at least, that you don't have a clue what Moya's music sounds like, IMHO, to be honest. No offence :)

No offense taken. But I would have voted "other" if I knew exactly which category to place it under. lol - it would have been a lot easier if it was "other[s]"! Then I would say folk, celtic, and world. And from what I hear of the clips of Two Horizons (everyone, I don't have the whole CD yet and I haven't heard it yet, either, so don't blast me!), it seems, too me, to be sort-of light-poppy. Or so that's what I call it! But I definitely wouldn't classify it as pop music.

-Greg

PostPosted: Fri Sep 26, 2003 7:43 am
by Dennisa
I voted for other because I think she has a style that is called Modern Celtic, how about that?

bye bye, Dennis

PostPosted: Sun Sep 28, 2003 5:09 pm
by the whistleplayer
I would say 'other', I think her music is quite unique. Like Jim I would call it 'Brennan-music'. It would definately suit Bartley's tourist cd played in Leo's :wink:
I don't think it is 'Celtic' music, because I think that 'Celtic music' doesn't exist. For details, or discussion, visit my website (www.geocities.com/andrea_clannad) 8)

PostPosted: Sun Sep 28, 2003 8:13 pm
by Embers
I voted for 'Not sure' because I really don't understand too much about classifying music. I seem to like music that can't be put into any cathegory. Enya and Moya... well, Enya is said to have her own genre - simply Enya. Can't Moya's music just be called 'Moya' then? :D

Hmmm... Or how about a nice new cathegory called Brennan, for these wonderful Irish ladies? :wink: :idea:

PostPosted: Sat Oct 16, 2004 4:19 pm
by mise
Well I thought I would digg up this topic and give it a new life.
I voted for other. I do not believe that being a christian makes your music christian, nor do I think New Age defines Máire's music. To me New Age music is a continues drone and very much synthesizer music, very unlike Máire's music. So other it is! I think it is contempory music with a close relation to the folk section.

Does that make any sense? :wink:

PostPosted: Sat Oct 16, 2004 5:04 pm
by AndyPandy
I voted "not sure" because I don't really know what new age is supposed to mean, and what happens when new age becomes old age? Its not a term that I understand really.
I wouldn't put her in the Christian category, as not all her songs are related to her faith and you don't have to be Christian to listen to them anyway.